Best K-Cup Flavors You Can Use with Your Keurig Coffee Maker


This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn commissions from qualifying purchases. Please read the full disclosure here.

The Keurig coffee maker has been a revelation for coffee aficionados who are short on time but need that vital caffeine kick each morning. Keurig took things a step above and beyond by introducing several different flavors for their customers’ leisure over the years. Drinking coffee has never been as enjoyable of an experience until Keurig came out with their remarkable new flavors.

You might be wondering what the best K-Cup flavors are. With so many flavors to choose from, it can become overwhelming to decide which of them beat the rest for the mantle of being the best. Here is when we come in to make things easier for you.

We’ve done the hard work and research for you to bring you our top five picks for the best K-Cup flavors. In our list, you will find reviews of each of the best K-Cup flavors along with what customers have to say about them.

Please note that this page reviews the flavors of different branded coffee roasts. If you are interested in flavored coffee (like hazelnut), please visit our page that reviews flavored k-cups.

We understand that everybody’s preferences for flavored coffee are different. These reviews will give you a better idea of what to expect when you’re looking for the best K-Cup flavors to use with your Keurig coffee maker.

Summary of The Best K-Cup Flavors

ProductKey Features
Breakfast Blend Light Roast Coffee by Green Mountain Coffee Roasters●    A light roast coffee blend
●    Certified kosher product
●    Ethical business practice company
Death Cup Dark Roast Blend by Death Wish Coffee Co.●    A dark roast coffee blend
●    Exceptionally strong coffee
●    A double dose of caffeine
Classic Cinnamon Roll Light Roast Blend Coffee by Cinnabon●    A light roast coffee blend
●    Tastes like classic cinnamon rolls
●    Certified kosher product
Decaf Dark Roast Blend Coffee by Peet’s Coffee●    A dark roast coffee blend
●    Decaf coffee
●    It is a rich-tasting decaf blend
Pike Place Medium Roast Blend Coffee by Starbucks●    Reputable coffee brand
●    A medium roast coffee blend
●    Notes of cocoa taste

The 5 Best K-Cup Flavors

Breakfast Blend Light Roast Blend Coffee by Green Mountain Coffee Roasters

The Breakfast Blend Light Roast Blend Coffee is our overall pick for the best K-Cup flavor. This light and aromatic coffee have plenty of factors going for it that make it our top pick. It is a flavorful coffee blend that has a mild enough level of caffeine to make it suitable for most coffee lovers. It still manages to give you a nice start to the day as you ease into your morning routine.

Key Features

There are several excellent qualities about this coffee that make it a favorite. Its delicious taste is, of course, one of the primary reasons it is one of the best K-Cup flavors you can buy. Made by Green Mountain Coffee Roasters, this coffee is sustainably sourced with a silky smooth and nutty flavor. Made using 100% Arabica beans, the Breakfast Blend is also a certified Orthodox Union Kosher product.

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters is dedicated to sustainable business practices. This ethically sourced coffee comes from the mountains in different areas of the world. The company makes sure it retains the richness and unique coffee flavors native to the source. All of the coffee comes from small farm businesses and locally owned companies. Flavorful and rich, the coffee aligns with environmentally friendly practices followed by Green Mountain Roasters. You can enjoy a delicious coffee without feeling guilty about your impact on the environment.

Customer Reviews

Customers generally love our top pick for the best K-Cup flavor. Many customers enjoy its ability to deliver a delicious flavor without being too strong or bitter. Most customers love the fact that they can enjoy great value for money with the Breakfast Blend by Green Mountain.

Nothing can be perfect. There are customers who did not have a good experience with this product. Some customers have reported that the coffee pods tend to explode in their Keurig coffee maker, and that creates quite a mess to clean up. Quality control is a problematic factor since some of the coffee pods of this K-Cup flavor come with faulty seals that lead to blowouts in the coffee maker. Several customers do not like the higher price of the K-Cup flavor.

Pros

  • It is a flavorful coffee
  • It is a mild and light roast blend
  • The coffee is a certified kosher product
  • The coffee is ethically sourced

Cons

  • The product is a little pricey
  • There are quality control issues with some coffee pods

Our Take

The Breakfast Blend by Green Mountain Coffee Roasters is an excellent K-Cup flavor. It has a mild strength that suits most coffee drinkers, and it has a delicious flavor at the same time. The K-Cup flavor fetches a higher price tag due to sustainable practices. Still, we feel that it offers you a good value for money for the quality of coffee you get.

Check out Price and Reviews on Amazon

Death Cup Dark Roast Blend by Death Wish Coffee Co.

Death Wish is an odd name to come across if you are looking for a cup of your favorite beverage to start a fantastic morning. If you are aware of the name, you will know that this is not just any name. Death Wish Coffee Co. is one of the biggest names when it comes to substantially strong coffee. They partnered with Keurig to make arguably one of the best K-Cup flavors you can buy.

Key Features

This is a coffee not suitable for use for beginners. These coffee pods pack twice the amount of caffeine any regular product will. If you are an avid coffee drinker who needs twice the caffeine dose to get your day started, the Death Cup Dark Roast Blend by Death Wish Coffee Co. is the way to go. This is a bold and dark roast that packs a serious punch.

Death Wish Coffee Co. is a small operation compared to some of the bigger coffee makers. The company has become increasingly popular over recent years due to its success. Despite becoming more popular, Death Wish retains its boutique method of roasting its coffee. It uses the latest technological developments to make robust coffee with a bold taste that is never bitter.

You get a robust and complex flavor profile with this K-Cup flavor, but it is never acidic like several other dark roast coffees are. The coffee is quite strong and flavorful, but it also happens to be an expensive product. Its complex flavor delivers subtle notes of cherry and chocolate that smooth out the potent coffee. You won’t have to worry about getting an acidic taste with this coffee due to the extraction method and additional taste of cherry and chocolate.

Customer Reviews

Customers have attested to the promise of a greater caffeine kick that Death Wish Coffee Co. offers its customers. They have reported that the coffee delivers its message across with packaging appropriate to what it provides. Many customers consider it one of the best Keurig coffee pods they have ever used.

While most customers love the Death Cup by Death Wish Coffee Co., there were several who have complained about the packaging of the coffee pods. These K-Cups are made using recyclable materials to make the product more environmentally friendly. It is also the reason why some customers reported blowouts from the K-Cups. The price is also an issue with this product. Customers who cannot get enough of it will happily pay the high price for this coffee, but it is considerably pricier than the average K-Cup flavor you can get in the market.

Pros

  • It is a rich and strong coffee
  • The coffee has double the dose of caffeine compared to regular products
  • The product is tasty and strong without being bitter
  • A boutique roasting method ensures consistency and high quality in the coffee

Cons

  • The packaging is subpar quality
  • It is an exceptionally expensive product

Our Take

We think the Death Cup by Death Wish Coffee Co. is arguably the best coffee for serious coffee drinkers. If you need a strong dose of caffeine, there are no other readymade products that can compete with the Death Wish. Its recyclable packaging is an admirable effort by the brand, but it also means it can create a mess with occasional blowouts in the coffee maker. It is a novelty product with an expensive price tag. Unsuitable for the beginner coffee drinker, it is an ideal choice for people who love a strong cup of joe in the morning.

Check out Price and Reviews on Amazon

Classic Cinnamon Roll Light Roast Blend Coffee by Cinnabon

The third product on our list of the best K-Cup flavors comes from a well-known brand. Cinnabon is a coffee maker with a reputation for the best cinnamon rolls in the world. Keurig partnered with the renowned pastry making a coffee brand to create the Cinnabon Classic Cinnamon Roll K-Cup Coffee. This light roast blend coffee has the taste of coffee and a cinnamon roll.

Key Features

This cinnamon roll flavored coffee is as close as coffee can get to having a pastry flavor without losing its integrity as coffee. It is a certified kosher product that is infused with cinnamon and brown sugar to deliver the classic cinnamon roll taste that Cinnabon has made a name for itself with. There is some additional flavoring in the coffee that delivers the flavor of the iconic icing by Cinnabon for its cinnamon rolls.

The Cinnabon flavor is perhaps the most significant quality of this K-Cup flavor. Keurig has made many flavored coffees while partnering with various brands. This partnership has become very successful with the Classic Cinnamon Light Roast Blend Coffee. One thing you will notice is that the coffee flavor takes a back seat as the cinnamon flavor dominates the prepared beverage.

The coffee content itself is a light roast blend that gives you a mild caffeine dose to help you get a fantastic start to the morning. You can even enjoy the mild strength as an evening coffee for a day indoors. The exceptional flavor of the coffee makes it taste like a liquified cinnamon roll as opposed to a coffee.

Customer Reviews

The Classic Cinnamon Roll Light Roast Blend Coffee by Cinnabon has its customers divided. Most customers love this light roast for its delivery on the promise of a cinnamon roll flavor. Customers reported that this K-Cup flavor is as close as they have gotten with coffee to a pastry flavor.

At the same time, many customers who are avid coffee drinkers and coffee purists do not appreciate the flavor. They feel that a cup of coffee should taste like coffee. Even flavored coffee should retain its coffee flavor. Coffee lovers who like their morning cup of joe strong and unsweetened did not like it. It does not deliver a high caffeine dose, and it has a slightly sweeter taste without the need to add any sugar.

Pros

  • It has a distinct taste from a very popular brand
  • The coffee has a lightly roasted blend with mild caffeine content
  • The coffee tastes like a classic cinnamon roll as advertised

Cons

  • The cinnamon roll taste can be overpowering

Our Take

We think it is a fantastic K-Cup flavor for the casual coffee drinker and someone who loves a sweet beverage with a mild caffeine kick. It is one of the best tasting K-Cup flavors in the market by a mile. It can give you the perfect start to the day if you are a Cinnabon fan because it tastes unmistakably like the brand’s pastries. If you’re someone who enjoys strong coffee with a more traditionally coffee-like flavor, this might not suit your needs.

Check out Price and Reviews on Amazon

Decaf Dark Roast Blend Coffee by Peet’s Coffee

If you are someone who loves to drink coffee, but you do not always want it for the caffeine, we have included a decaf blend in our top picks for the best K-Cup flavors. The Decaf Dark Roast Blend Coffee by Peet’s Coffee is the best-decaffeinated coffee you will find in the market. Decaf coffee usually has a reputation for being just a watery beverage that has a faint taste of what could resemble coffee. With this product, you will never be able to guess that it is a decaf product based on its flavor.

Key Features

There are few coffee products out there that offer you a genuine coffee experience without having caffeine. Peet’s Coffee is a brand reputed for its high-quality products. Keurig partnered with the boutique coffee brand to produce its decaf blend that maximizes the taste of coffee without a hint of caffeine content.

The company uses innovative extraction methods to get the coffee flavor from its dark roasted coffee beans. It uses a sophisticated water system combined with an advanced carbon filter to achieve extraction. This product delivers the signature complex flavor of Alfred Peet’s coffee with a rich and interesting blend of the finest quality. This dark roast delivers the full-bodied and smoky flavor that you can expect from the brand’s caffeinated version without giving you the caffeine dose.

Peet’s Coffee uses the same care and high standards when it comes to carefully source the beans for this decaf blend. It uses carefully selected beans from Latin America that give you a rich, crispy, fresh, and pleasant coffee flavor. Deep-roasted in small batches by hand, Peet’s Coffee imparts the most flavor and aroma in this coffee to give you a satisfying coffee drinking experience without worrying about any caffeine content.

Customer Reviews

There are some quality control issues with this K-Cup flavors. Some customers have reported that a few cups they have had of this coffee taste older or stale. For the most part, this decaf coffee delivers a complex and aromatic flavor to satisfy the thirst for coffee without any caffeine. Customers were also happy with the intensity of its flavor. Where other decaf blend products produce mostly watery coffee, this gives a full-bodied dark roast flavor of the highest standards. Some customers have also reported issues with the packaging of the coffee, and it is prone to occasional blowouts in the coffee maker.

Pros

  • The coffee has a rich and complex taste
  • It does not feel like it is a decaf coffee due to a genuine dark roast flavor
  • Uses sophisticated methods to extract the most flavor and aroma without the caffeine content

Cons

  • Some customers have reported a stale or old taste
  • There are reports of subpar packaging

Our Take

We think it is the ideal product for coffee drinkers who can no longer enjoy caffeine but still have a craving for the beverage. The dark roast blend comes as close to delivering a genuine coffee drinking experience in a decaf product. There is no beating Peet’s decaf blend if you are looking for a high-quality decaf product.

Check out Price and Reviews on Amazon

Pike Place Medium Roast Blend Coffee by Starbucks

A list of the best K-Cup flavors would not be complete if Starbucks were not on it. Starbucks is the global giant when it comes to excellence in coffee. If you are a fan of Starbucks Coffee, you will appreciate its Pike Place Medium Roast Blend Coffee that it made in partnership with Keurig. It is a medium roast blend coffee that delivers a smooth and mellow flavor.

Key Features

Starbucks Coffee’s Pike Place Roast is one of the coffee giant’s most well-rounded flavors. It has a sophisticated flavor of coffee with its medium roast. Soft and mellow notes of cocoa and toasted nuts underline this blend to give you a sublime and smooth feel in your mouth. The smooth and balanced flavors of this medium roast blend make it one of the most approachable coffee flavors made for the Keurig coffee maker.

Keurig and Starbucks Coffee, like many other brands, are moving towards more sustainable business practices. A significant issue with Keurig’s K-Cups used to be the environmental impact of the K-Cups, but that is no longer a problem. The Pike Place Medium Roast Blend Coffee by Starbucks Coffee is made using recyclable products.

The Pike Place Medium Roast Blend is an ideal and classic flavor for coffee drinkers who want a product for everyday consumption. It has a rich java flavor which is smooth. The blend is achieved by carefully picked Latin American coffee beans that deliver a subtle aroma of cocoa and toasted nuts in every sip.

Customer Reviews

Customers generally enjoyed this K-Cup flavor because it gives them a taste of their favorite coffee brand without the need to go to an outlet to buy one. There are many customers who actively enjoy the Pike Place Medium Roast at Starbucks, who are disappointed with this. They have reported that the K-Cup counterpart has an excellent flavor, but it is not quite the same as what they enjoy at Starbucks Coffee.

Pros

  • The coffee has a smooth taste
  • It has subtle undertones of cocoa and toasted nut flavors
  • The coffee has a full-flavored roast

Cons

  • The coffee does not deliver the same taste as you can get at a Starbucks outlet

Our Take

We think it is definitely one of the best-tasting K-Cup flavors in the market. It gives you the quality product you can expect from Starbucks, and you can make the beverage in the comfort of your home. There is, however, the fact that you can’t replicate this flavor with an ordinary Keurig K-cup coffee pod that leaves some coffee drinkers disappointed.

Check out Price and Reviews on Amazon

Final Thoughts

This brings us to the end of our reviews for the top picks when it comes to the best K-Cup flavors. Each of the coffee pods offers a different experience that we feel coffee lovers with different inclinations might enjoy.

When it comes to the type of coffee and flavor, we understand that everybody has their preferences. It is the reason why we have tried to include the top picks to suit the needs of a variety of coffee drinkers with different preferences.

We hope the reviews of each product will help you make the ideal purchase decision for the best K-Cup flavor. If you still feel lost, we will recommend the Breakfast Blend Light Roast Blend Coffee by Green Mountain. It is an ideal beverage for regular coffee drinkers who enjoy a standard cup of joe.

However, if you’re more of an experienced coffee drinker and need an added boost to your caffeine dose in the morning, the Death Cup Dark Roast Blend Coffee by Death Wish Co. might be the perfect fit for you. With twice as much caffeine as any other brand, it is sure to get you up and moving for an active day.

Each of the products we’ve reviewed is fantastic in its own way. The choice is ultimately going to be on your personal preference. We hope this article helps you on your journey of exploring the many wonderful flavors you can enjoy in your Keurig coffee maker.